What are direct and indirect forecasting methods?

In the context of cash flow forecasting, direct and indirect methods refer to the two different approaches used to estimate future cash inflows and outflows: direct forecasting relies on actual cash movements, while indirect forecasting is based on accounting statements.

Direct cash flow forecasting relies on detailed data, such as accounts payable and accounts receivable, to project cash flows over shorter periods, typically 13 weeks or less. In contrast, indirect cash flow forecasting begins with accounting statements (e.g., profit and loss or balance sheets) and adjusts for non-cash items, making it more suitable for long-term projections and strategic planning.

‍

What is the direct forecasting method?

The direct forecasting method involves tracking actual cash receipts and payments for transactions that have occurred or are expected to occur. This approach provides a real-time view of cash activity, which is crucial for day-to-day liquidity management. This method is often used for 13-week cash flow forecasting and weekly or monthly forecasts generally.

Key characteristics:

• Based on real transactions and precise timing.
• Provides a clear view of liquidity over the short term.
• Often used for weekly or monthly forecasts.

How it works:

• Identify cash inflows: customer payments, interest receipts, refunds, etc.
• Identify cash outflows: accounts payable (AP) payments, salaries, tax obligations, loan repayments, etc.
• Sum inflows and outflows to project the net cash position.

Advantages:

• Highly accurate for short-term periods.
• Useful for managing day-to-day liquidity.
• Relies on actual transactional data, reducing uncertainty.

Disadvantages:

• Time-intensive, requiring up-to-date and detailed data.
• Limited applicability for long-term projections.

Use cases in cash flow forecasting:

• Managing working capital.
• Ensuring there is enough liquidity to meet short-term obligations.
• Preparing for periods of expected high cash demand (e.g., payroll).

‍

What is the indirect forecasting method?

Instead of using actual cash movements, this approach relies on indirect adjustments from net income. It starts with accounting statements—such as a profit and loss statement or balance sheet—and adjusts for non-cash items to estimate cash flows. It's typically used for long-term projections and strategic planning.

For example, a company’s forecasted cash flow statement—often included as part of its quarterly or annual budget or business plan—is derived indirectly from the forecasted income statement and balance sheet. Unlike the 13-week forecast, it’s intended to show the broad categories of where cash is generated and spent over a longer timeframe.

Key characteristics:

• Relies on financial models rather than actual transactions.
• Focuses on changes in working capital, depreciation, and financing activities.
• Suitable for long-term forecasts.

How it works:

1. Start with net income or EBITDA.
2. Adjust for non-cash items (e.g., depreciation, amortization).
3. Account for changes in working capital (e.g., accounts receivable, inventory, and accounts payable).
4. Include cash flows from financing and investing activities.

Advantages:

• Efficient for long-term projections.
• Links cash flow to broader financial statements and strategic goals.
• Useful for planning and understanding long-term trends.

Disadvantages:

• Less precise for short-term liquidity management.
• Assumptions about working capital changes or external factors can introduce uncertainty.

Use cases in cash flow forecasting:

• Developing multi-year strategic plans.
• Assessing the impact of major investments or financing decisions.
• Long-term budget planning and scenario analysis.